To recap—last night on V, the “Lizard Princess” got Nancy Kerriganed by mommy dearest and ended up beginning to build a relationship (equally manipulative) with Tyler’s mommy as well, Fifth Column High Commander Erica Evans.
All quite apropos, because “Fruition” was an episode all about Vs acting like humans, humans acting like Vs, and, picking up on last week’s title, the battle between “Hearts and Minds.”
When Agent Evans got the call about a violent attack on a V, she rushed to the hospital to find—much to her surprise—that the victim was Tyler’s girlfriend Lisa (however bruised and battered the poor girl may have been, Erica certainly would have recognized the red bra and panties Lisa was sporting the first time they met). But while Erica had known about the hidden cameras in the peace ambassador uniforms (and her son’s naivete), she’d broken her own rule trusting him even a little bit—and now got the biggest shock a parent could possibly have: my son is dating a reptile.
Of course, in characteristic low-key, low-voiced Elizabeth Mitchell fashion, Erica’s conversation at the end of the episode was a little less dramatic than the situation might have called for.
Tyler: I just wanted to make sure you’re okay with me… dating a V.
EE: It’s a little weird—not gonna lie.
Yes, yes it is a little weird. But human teens lying to their parents isn’t so weird as parents ordering their kid’s legs broken and face slashed open to make good theater for a press conference. Even before Erica found out that Anna was behind the attack, she saw the look of all-consuming terror on Lisa’s face when her mother came to take Erica’s place comforting her at the hospital. Even Erica in her shock had been genuinely horrified, and stayed by Lisa’s bedside even while the girl was sleeping—brushing her hair back from her face and holding her warmly. When Anna hugged her daughter, she smiled as sinisterly as only an evil alien queen can do, and Lisa, stiff, looked wide-eyed at Erica.
The two mother’s couldn’t have been much more different. While Lisa told doctor Joshua “My son’s in love with a V,” Anna thought she was being convincingly sincere when she told Erica—“Lisa is very fond of Tyler.”
But Lisa, as Joshua realized and told Erica later in this episode, is more than just “fond” of Tyler-of-the-vacant-expression (am I going to ship Lisa/Joshua one of these days? Quite possibly). She’s beginning to develop human emotions—which makes her perfect material for the Fifth Column. Or at least, for manipulation by the Fifth Column.
It’s interesting to note here that Erica and Anna might have more in common than they think. Anna, as we’ve known for a couple weeks now, has some nefarious plan involving Tyler—the details of which are still unknown. And though Erica’s compassion score is probably off the charts (exceeded only by Father Jack, who’s passed compassion and edged into the betazoid empath zone), she’s quite happy to use someone else’s kid too. Quoth Evans: “If she’s going to use my son then I’m sure as hell going to use her daughter.”
But Erica drew the line at involving her own Tyler. When Hobbes suggested (supported by Ryan) that they might bring the boy into the Fifth Column quadrilateral of trust, Erica adamantly refused. Consideration for her son’s safety? Ostensibly. But Tyler, they know now, is already in danger, and the only added danger that might come from telling her son about her secret life as a terrorist might be to the Fifthers themselves.
Tyler loved Lisa. That’s pretty well-established. And she, it seems, loves him back. From a strategic standpoint, there’s no reason to put anything between that mutual trust—especially when Lisa’s human emotions nearly had her confessing to her mother’s scheme in framing Hobbes and climatologist Lawrence Parker for her attack.
Erica recognizes the value in teen love toward the end of the episode. After Tyler apologizes for lying and calls her “my hero” for catching the man who (says Anna) attacked Lisa, Erica responds with this warm peace offering: “Tyler, I was wrong about the Visitors—you were right. I’d like to get to know Lisa better, and Anna too, if that’s all right with you.”
Erica’s qualms, it appears, don’t lie with using Tyler—but with giving him more information than he needs to know. She’s manipulating her son just as surely as Anna is her daughter. Though, to Erica’s credit, she’d probably never take a crowbar to Tyler’s kneecaps.
Kyle Hobbes is another Fifther to reveal some suspiciously V-like tactics in “Fruition.” But whereas Erica wants to promote the rebel cause by encouraging the development of Lisa’s empathy, Hobbes prefers eliminating emotions.
Ryan’s been sporting a relatively flat affect for the past couple weeks, even since Val found out his true identity and the fact that her baby’s some sort of hybrid (Val might want to consider checking out Splice in theaters for useful parenting tips). On a stakeout outside Parker’s Chinatown apartment, Ryan confessed to Father Jack that he didn’t think he could continue fighting without Val, and the love she’d supported him with.
Jack Landry gives the conventional priestly response— have faith.
Kyle Hobbes’s advice is a little different. In the Fifth Column bunker, surrounded by his spy gear and stolen hard drives, he gives us this gem of personal insight:
“When special ops soldiers go to war, they don’t carry any family mementos, no photos, nothing. You know why? Because they can be taken from you and used against you. In war, emotions can get you killed. Leave your feelings for her behind—burn any trace of them out of your heart.”
It’s an interesting comment, considering that Erica, just minutes before, gave Lisa a picture of her son to carry with her—“for strength.”
Hobbes is, in effect, teaching Ryan how to be a V. Because while Anna kills those who fail the empathy test (failure meaning showing empathy), Hobbes’s ruthless pragmatism would make him a perfect lieutenant.
And so, with this insight into the mind of a mercenary, we learn that Hobbes really doesn’t have too much emotional attachment to… anything (there goes my Hobbes/Even theory). That is, anything except himself and his own interests.
Anna’s minions framed Hobbes and Larry Parker for the supposed Fifth Column attack on Lisa. Of course, Hobbes was too busy blowing shuttles out of the sky to possibly be involved—and Parker was a chubby academic with thick glasses and a twitchy demeanor (but to be fair, being on a V hit list might do that to anyone). The reason Parker was a target stems from his research on global warming. Apparently, he and a team of scientists developed a compound that would help reduce the carbon dioxide levels in the atmosphere. Unfortunately, the compound had a dangerous side-effect—it produced fish, amphibian, and reptile-killing algae.
No wonder the Vs wanted him gone. What’s more confusing is why Hobbes would steal his hard drive without telling his Fifth Column compatriots that he had potentially the most important weapon against the Visitors in his possession.
Answer: Because Hobbes isn’t as human as the rest of them.
Meeting with Marcus in a dark alley, Hobbes makes a deal to trade the research for a fat bank account and a “clean slate,” or, “everything the Vs have on me.” Which begs the question—what exactly do the Vs have one him?
Likely they don’t know he’s Fifth Column. They do know that he very likely murdered five helpless scientists (Parker’s fellow researchers, who had all “disappeared” in the previous months). They also framed him twice, and got him on the FBI’s most wanted list.
That’s a pretty dirty slate—and if he can be cleared with the human authorities, he won’t have to shave his sinister (and quite recognizable) mustache and goatee—but Hobbes’s betrayal makes it entirely possible there’s a whole lot more.
Ryan asked him, “Since when do you worry about anyone else but yourself?” After this week, we can pretty safely say the answer is—never. And in another case of human/V crossover, Hobbes’s characterization is starting to parallel Anna’s more and more. As Joshua said to Erica, when she couldn’t believe Anna would injure her own daughter: “She’s not human. She will do anything to get what she wants.”
That’s the problem for the Fifth Column these days. Will stopping the Vs make them like their enemies? Father Jack raised the question last week in “Hearts and Minds,” but the debate raged on and came to (get ready for it) “Fruition” last Tuesday. With the season coming to a close, we’ll find out soon.
On a lighter note, Anna’s eggs are about to hatch and Lisa’s considering fratricide (that’s what human emotions bring—love for Tyler and the desire to kill thousands of babies). And Anna, I’m pretty sure, was reading off a Kindle.
This has been the one-year anniversary post of the Scattering’s birth. Happy birthday blog!